Submissions are closed! All submitted maps have 24 hours after this post to make any last minute updates to their maps. I'll have the voting form prepared later today.

July 2018 Public Voting Link: https://goo.gl/forms/IrZ0cjFgBLl9KC5n2

There are 6 MTC entries. Download all of them here.

In the voting sheet, give your score before your feedback (0 to 10, decimals are allowed). If you have comments, leave them right after your score. For example:

7.8 - Too much water!

Everyone is allowed to judge, even players who submitted maps (your score on your own maps will be removed, so feel free to give it a 10)

Every map pair will be judged with a decimal number from 0 (bad) to 10 (good). All votes greater than/equal to 7 or less than/equal to 4 require constructive feedback on why you gave it that score

Note that you have to judge each pair of stages entirely! You cannot judge only half of it, and you must play both maps. If you are not able to finish one or both maps, your vote can still count! Please only leave that as a very last resort, and still judge the entire pair fairly

You need to verify your vote by making a post here. (for example: "Voted ")

One best and one worst vote for each map pair will be ignored if more than 10 people vote

The overall score will be a 50/50 mixture of the average public score and the average internal score

You must have access to and vote on all map pairs for your votes to count

---

A panel of judges will also judge the maps.
This internal voting will follow the format of:
Theme (20p) | Creativity (10p) | Fun (10p) | Detail (10p)

All voting will close on August 5th, 2018 at midnight EST.

Last edited by Arkive, 2018-07-25 01:33:50

Voted

nevermind

voted

The votes are in, and we have our results!

  Lars wins with less than a single point of margin!

Very cool but difficult map. Mesmerizing atmosphere. - Voyager

Awesome integration of the custom scenery blocks into the route... - AR »rexine

...the feeling of a clean run is nothing less than fantastic. - Arkive

  Plaste put up an equally solid map, and snags second place!

[mtc] Mordnilap (green) by   Plaste

Both tracks are equally well calculated and flow well. - AR »rexine

Every corner feels natural... - Arkive

Both routes are technical but still flowy. - Voyager

  AR »rexine obtains a well deserved third place!

MTC ~ Old 45 (Side A) by   AR »rexine

Nice flow and a clear path... - Fedayk1n

Some nice small details with objects throughout. - BushMonkey

I always feel a bit partial to Valley, and this course shows why. - Arkive

In addition to the battle for first, Xyromad was quite close to getting on the podium! His course "Lost Island" was also found to be within one point of Rexine's submission.

Lars, Plaste, and AR »rexine receive one front page track showcase of their choice (having less than 10 awards).


Find the full results and feedback here: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1kP1QpviE_10r7jrBkqd-TaPmthSd0PrGK2wGMmLhLjA/edit?usp=sharing

Thanks to all participants this month for joining in the contest, thanks to all those who publicly voted and gave their feedback.

If you're looking for more MTC action, then set your watches for the August 2018 MTC!

My comments are shorter this time around, so just note me if you want an extended comment about a map and a more throughout explanation of the points given