Hi irondragons.
I don't know what about other users, but when I say in an award that i didn't like this or that, i'm not forcing the author to consider it. When i say i didn't like something, i'm just informing the author that his track would maybe have been more appreciated without this bad point, then he's free to consider it or not.
Besides, "award" is just the name that was given to these posts under the screenie. What's so bad in including the bad points in it too ? Do we really have to post a second time in comments to talk about the bad points ? Is it a death or life question ?
Though you're right about that start. People who didn't take the time to read your author comments and find the short start version shouldn't be unpleasant when talking about it.