Nice catch! I forgot to add that (I was using the last MTC post as a base, so you can see how that got skipped over). The main post is now updated; author times must be between 30 seconds and 2 minutes. Both courses already submitted are within this limit.

February 2018 Public Voting Link: https://goo.gl/forms/3MqnKQZNzkDFEbja2

There are 20 MTC entries.

In the voting sheet, give your score before your feedback (0 to 10, half points are allowed), and then feedback right after it, for example:

# - feedbackfeedbackfeedback...

Everyone is allowed to judge, even players who submitted a map (give your own map a 10).

Every map will be judged with marks from 0 (bad) to 10 (good). All votes 7+ or 4- and lower require constructive feedback on why you gave it that score.

Note that you have to judge a stage entirely. You cannot judge only half of it. If you are not able to finish the map, your vote can still count, but please only leave that as a very last resort, and still judge the entire map fairly.

You need to verify your vote by making a post here. (for example: "Voted ")

One best and one worst vote for each map will be ignored if more than 10 people vote.

The overall score will be a 50/50 mixture of the average public score and the average internal score.

You must have access to all environments and vote for all maps for your votes to count.

---

A panel of judges will also judge the maps.
This internal voting will follow the format of:
Theme (20p) | Creativity (10p) | Fun (10p) | Detailwork, MT, Scenery (10p)

All voting will close on March 4th, 2018 at midnight EST.

Arkive says:
There are 20 MTC entries.

... on your google forms there are only 19 maps .

Thanks for the heads up! Eyebo's been notified (he's the one who made/can edit the form), so it should be fixed fairly soon.

It's updated now. Sorry about that.
FYI, no votes had been submitted yet.

Voted

Voted

Since we've still got to finish up our internal judging and there was some potential interest expressed, I've decided to reopen public voting for the moment. If you're still looking to send in your votes, now's the time to do so!

Voted for all the maps. Even though one, I decided to give the average of my other votes, because of how I felt about it. (Which turned out to be a 5)

Twenty entries rose to the challenge, and now we've got the final results calculated!

  Lars descends onto the podium with his winning entry!

Absolutely amazing adventure of a track! - Racho

I love the tunnel, the bridge... I love everything! - akilehad

I do love the dark underground bit ... it looked and felt really cool to drive in. - Keissla

  Plaste climbs into second place!

[MTC] Rising Hills by   Plaste

It flows spectacularly, with plenty of long, drawn out corners that feel great to get right. - Arkive

Wonderful flow. The map is beautifully put together. - AR »rexine

You gain more altitude than you imagine driving it with lots of undulating turns ... kept a nice natural pace and flow throughout the track. - Racho

Soaring into third, we have   Superal.nc!

MTC - Get Some Air by   Superal.nc

I love the atmosphere and the transitions. - akilehad

The most fun I had on any Stadium track in at least a few years... - Racho

Overall though, very impressive track, that almost feels like an oldschool speedtech re-imagined in tm2. - Keissla

Plaste and Superal were incredibly close, with less than one fifth of a point separating them! SolideZeehond and xrayjay had a similarly close difference. Snowman and akilehad were even closer, having less than one tenth of a point between them!

Lars, Plaste, and Superal receive one front page track showcase of their choice (having less than 10 awards).


Find the full results and feedback here: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1wB9YP6l7leVwjcx6bCAnQqj4ZjWek9Xqx-cXsPbMS1I/edit?usp=sharing

Thanks to all participants this month for joining in the contest, thanks to all those who publicly voted and gave their feedback. Special thanks to Racho and Eyebo, who helped me host my first MTC!

I hope you all enjoyed this month's contest! Head on over to the March 2018 MTC; the unique theme should provide an interesting challenge.

Last edited by Keissla.wp, 2018-03-10 22:36:43