Last day to post your submissions! (~21h left)

Deadline has passed and submissions are closed. Don't edit your tracks until the results are posted.

Judging sheets and tracklist will follow soon.

MTC May Public Voting Link: https://goo.gl/forms/q3phdT0mwAsaOoQV2

There are 13 MTC entries. Download them all here

In the voting sheet, give your score before your feedback (0 to 10, half points are allowed), and then feedback right after it, for example:

# - feedbackfeedbackfeedback...

Everyone is allowed to judge, even players who submitted a map (give your own map a 10).

Every map will be judged with marks from 0 (bad) to 10 (good). All votes 7+ or 4- and lower require constructive feedback on why you gave it that score.

Note that you have to judge a stage entirely. You cannot judge only half of it. If you are not able to finish the map, your vote can still count, but please only leave that as a very last resort, and still judge the entire map fairly.

You need to verify your vote by making a post here. (for example: "Voted ")

One best and one worst vote for each map will be ignored if more than 10 people vote.

The overall score will be a 50/50 mixture of the average public score and the average internal score.

You must have access to all environments and vote for all maps for your votes to count.

---

A panel of judges will also judge the maps.
This internal voting will follow the format of:
Theme (20p) | Creativity (10p) | Fun (10p) | Detailwork, MT, Scenery (10p)

All voting will close on June 10th, 2018 at midnight PDT.

Last edited by Racho, 2018-05-28 10:26:46

Voted

Slightly more than 36h left to vote!

Would be great to get more than 1 public vote.

Voted.

While the voting deadline has passed, I'm waiting for another public judge to finish (should be done by the end of the day). Also, to be honest, I myself haven't finished judging yet thanks to falling ill over the weekend with the head all mushy...
If anyone else wants to judge or is currently in the process of judging, just write me a PM here or on Discord (Racho#5863) and I'll keep the door open.

Results should be out sometime tomorrow though.

All judges have submitted their votes and I've closed the public voting.

Results will be posted later today!

Results!!!

  MeKecek

Wonderful map. Everything is perfect. - AR »rexine

nice to hunt, flow is on point, very competitive, reuse is very clear and nice - eFFecT

I really like the first 2 re-uses. - Racho

  Fedayk1n

MTC - Harbor Construction by   Fedayk1n

Very cool track that almost feels like a new environment. - pjw

some neat turn ideas with the containers - Lars

The construction site feel of the track was really well done - Keissla

  pastek

MTC>>Rushing for the deadline by   pastek

Cool scenery and MT work - Keissla

Fun, creative, and well-constructed map. - AR »rexine

nice creative map, good scenery - eFFecT


MeKecek, Fedayk1n, and shadokk receive one front page track showcase of their choice (having less than 10 awards)


Find the full results and feedback (see other tabs in the sheet) here:
https://drive.google.com/open?id=1ljzQCE0VPjXzwCX4ipL4zJSGVhG6-BCaDDbtW-AUais



Thanks to all participants this month for joining in the contest, thanks to all those who publicly voted and gave their feedback. Sorry it took a bit longer this month, but stuff happened... and we still only had to delay publishing the results for 3 days.

Hope you all enjoyed building one of the classic MTC themes. If you feel like you're in shape to tackle another MTC, head over to MTC June 2018!

Last edited by Racho, 2018-06-14 13:25:30