i will be a judge when i don't participate into the contest, this will happen when i don't like the theme of the month.

officially joining as Judge is for everyone of the community, but it seems that a perfect judge should be:
-A Veteran of earlier MTCs and previous Trackmanias
-An expert that beats every AT time
-He Built Tracks that reached already 100+ Awards
-He should have enough time to review every Track for atleast 1 hour
-He should have enough cookies for everyone
well thats a joke
Being a Judge is as much ungrateful as being referee in a football match. You cant make the right decisions for everyone. To be honest i only built dozens of Platfrom Tracks for Previuos Trackmanias and i never became famous or well known in any Trackmania Community, but i wanted to be part of it. So i am NOT Judge at this MTC but i wrote down many things and maybe you (the participants of this MTC) are interested in what i wrote even when i am only an average Player and it most likely is not what you expect.
Judge Draft
EDIT
This is my final post in this Topic so dont start to argue about me give me a PrivateMessage if you think it is necessary.

That's dedication. Maybe you should apply to be an actual judge. Sorry for mis...uh...judging you.

Just to remind you, the deadline will be here in a few hours!

Submissions have been closed! Thank you for participating, the judges will be revealed soon.

Thank you all for participating!

The thread will be locked until the results are ready. The judges will receive their judging sheets today, and we will update their progress to this thread.

The next MTC starts at the beginning of December!

We're looking for one more judge! We have 4 right now, and a fifth would be really nice to have. Please contact me or KekX!

Results in a few minutes!

Here are the official results of the second ManiaExchange Monthly Track Contest (MTC), November 2011

When you watch the results, remember that the lowest and the highest score of each track were not ignored because we had only 4 judges.

This month, the winner is Tobbe, who wins by a clear margin of 6 points! I can't help quoting lolig, who left such a heart-warming comment: "This map is a pearl lost somewhere between al the other stones and shells in the sea, If you know what I mean...".

RESULTS

(184.5 points, max. 200 points possible)

[MTC] Hellas Platform by Enai Siaion (178.5 points)

MTC|Lapsus [No_SC] by Nimrod (178.5 points)

4. [MTC] The Dark Side by zipperke
5. 3KINGS (MTC) by REHVEN
6. [MTC] Oversteer by Jonkster
7. (MTC) The Slide of Fun 3 by Exploding Lemon
8. Lets do it! [MTC] by 2bfree
8. What's that smell? (MTC) by hoheb
10. Ototoxic Drifts(MTC) by hypnosmurf

See judging sheet for pos. 11-20.

Thanks to all participants and congratulations to the top 3!

Here you can download the whole results with the scores and comments of all judges (xls spreadsheet).
Osaka's scores were rounded in the "Total Results" section for reasons of consistency

A special THANKS goes to the judges (lolig, Osaka, Anaerob, master94ga)! Thanks for the time and effort you invested!

ManiaExchange

There are still 11 days left to build a track for the December MTC. Check it out here!

4th place
i find some of the comments from the judges nice, they like the intro and atmosphere but only give 2.5/5 for MT
just doesn't feel fair..